I'm busy working on my blog posts. Watch this space!
Can't Stop, Won't Stop (book review)
January 11, 2018
I’ve had Jeff Chang’s “Can’t Stop, Won’t Stop” sitting on my shelf for a few years. I’d been waiting for a time I could spend the amount of time I felt it would be necessary to fully absorb this book which seems to have become a classic text on Hip-Hop history. In December I decided it was time – I would consume the book during my yearly two-thousand mile round-trip to visit my family in North Dakota during the holidays.
I was immediately struck by the thoroughness – the history begins in mid-20th-century New York and Jamaica. However, I kept thinking to myself, “when is he going to get to the music?”
As it turns out, “Can’t Stop, Won’t Stop” is less a history of Hip-hop MUSIC and more about the political, cultural, and socio-economic factors which influenced Hip-hop culture and, in turn, Hip-hop music. Yet, even within Hip-hop culture, the book primarily focuses on the culture within New York City, and later, in Los Angeles/Compton.
At points I was tempted to skip ahead, but kept telling myself, “this has got to be leading to SOMETHING important.” It rarely did. I was especially tempted to skip ahead during the long passages detailing various gang wars.
I appreciate the passion and detail Mr. Chang put into this work, but I feel there was too much emphasis and too much space devoted to irrelevant details.
I read this as a scholar and musicologist with my handy pen ready to underline, take notes, and write in the margins. I left the book feeling like I had just read an interesting collection of historical anecdotes that had little to do with the music. This book will stay in my musicology library, but only as a supplemental, background text – not as musicological study of the music.